He has a temper that he cant control and will not do anything about it. To ask a school-related question to our panel of teachers, email. I have given this advice before to others: I would give your daughter three to six months to find a job and a place to stay, or else youll have to throw them out. Her life will be just fine if being called beautiful is her biggest problem. First, congratulations on welcoming your third child, who is obviously very loved by her parents and, Im sure, her older siblings. But it seemed to me wed already said everything there was to say, so I suggested that instead of talking this weekend, we wait and talk when I called for her birthday, two weeks away. I dont know what her inappropriate discipline looks like, but if she has ever struck your 5-year-old, of course you shouldnt allow her to be around him. Over the past few months, she has developed this habit of saying things like kill me or I want to die when shes not happy about something. At the beginning . I can say this honestly and without bias. I want to teach him that its OK to have big feelings, to cry, to really love things that boys arent stereotypically into, but I also dont want to raise him with unrealistic/sexist views about love. Dear Care and. ), As to your second question: For goodness sake, stay out of it. The collection features some of the most. Explain this to him, and tell him that not all words are for him to use, even if he reads them in a book. Submit it here or post it in the Slate Parenting Facebook group. (Im not saying this is fair. Im just saying they may be doing the best they can under very difficult circumstances. I Despise My In-Laws. So, what could you say when youre ready? I Despise My In-Laws. A wave of claustrophobia closed in on him. My wife feels strongly that this is a kind of appropriation, and that this title should be something special for my mother. 10. Still, I worry that when someone hears a lie over and over, a person can start to believe it is true. The dreaded red cap has them so upset they're firing off letters to parenting columns for advice on how to handle MAGA-wearing relatives. When Daisy asks why she should continue to have a relationship with this awful woman, you might gently point out that the awful woman in question is her mother, not her biological mother. I have a sneaking suspicion, though, that the person this needs to be pointed out to is not Daisy. Care and Feeding is Slates parenting advice column. 2.5 Baths. I Played a Card Game With My Fianc to See Who Does the Most Housework. ); if thats not possible, ask him not to disturb you when you are in a session. Recently a friend of a friends brother died of cancer. 3 Beds. ), is just an impossible, unsustainable situation for your kid. Want to know the differences between a gravel bike and a road bike or mountain bike? It is beyond ridiculous, and I am sick of it. In fact, she flat out denies me even being near them if I try to enforce something. My stepbrothers are 9 (twins), and my half-sisters are 6 and 4. Reclaim your life and sanity by putting your foot down today. Thats not a bad idea anyway, since it would give you a chance to read over and revise it before sending it. Maybe theyll decide to try couples counseling. I am intimately familiar with trying to replace she doesnt want to talk to me with shes busy, and I learned a long time agolong before I had a grown-up daughter, back when I was the grown-up daughter and my father wouldnt think twice about sending me the sort of link (if hed known how to send a link) you sent your kidthat if you want to have a good relationship with adult children, you should assume competency and never offer advice unless asked for it. Theres an endless list of alternatives for names that should satisfy both of you, and you need to do whatever it takes to find them. Shes had obvious crushes on people of all sorts throughout her life, from her buff neighbor, captain of her schools mens hockey team, to her eye doctors female receptionist intern to her best friends older brother. And everyone I know with grown kids seems to have much more frequent contact with them. This should absolutely be a hill you should die on. There is not a huge difference in what it will cost us, but enough to make a difference. Submit it here or post it in the Slate Parenting Facebook group. Not to use a popular buzz phrase, but your role in this is to provide psychological safety and reassure him that everything will be OK, because it will be. Care and Feedingis Slate'sparenting advicecolumn. It happens to the best of us at that age (and a month isnt so long! She should be intrinsically motivated to do whatever it takes to provide for her family and live on her own as someone who has been an adult for 17 years. My husband runs his own business and works crazy hours. "The other portals are of ebony. They mostly manage because they have no mortgage, although when an unexpected expense comes up I often pitch in. He cant run or keep up with young kids like he used to. Heck, I would even go to a marriage counselor or therapist with this but dont give in. While the columnist tries to talk the distressed relative off the ledge with words of calm just back away slowly . In the meantime, I wish you fortitude. Have a question for Care and Feeding? I know I need to go back into therapy, but Im home all the time now with my husband and I dont have the freedom and privacy to talk that this would require. Have a question for Care and Feeding? Dear Care and. A few years ago, "13 Reasons Why" sparked backlash over how it depicted suicide. How can I support Slate so I can keep reading all the advice from Dear Prudence, Care and Feeding, Ask a Teacher, and How to Do It? Dear Care and Feeding, My daughter is beautiful. But where your daughters are concerned, Id suggest you be frank with them about your wish to connect with them. Thats not the point. Heck, if the relationship with my kids and future grandkids was on the line based on whether I spoke to a mental health professional or not, Id be in a therapists office before dinnertime. Maybe start with, Dad, I love you very much, but I have to be honest with you. How do I set up a happy life for my family while Im secretly harboring such anger and resentment? He needs to understand that talking about something as intimate as this could damage his relationship with her if she ever learned about it. Take the nice words graciously, dont make a big production of it, and move on with your day. A book based on the column titled Dear Prudence: Liberating Lessons from Slate.com's Beloved Advice Column will be released on April 4, 2023. Care and Feeding is Slate's parenting advice column. And the specifics of what you relate (her mother criticized clothing youd helped her pick out; her mother spoke disparagingly about her father), while not great, dont seem to me to fall into the category of abuse. Nor does an insensitive, dismissive remark about PMS. At the time they were 11, 9 and 7, and I was . Slate now has four advice columns Care and Feeding, for parenting advice; Dear Prudence, for general relationship/being-a-human questions; How to Do It, for sex advice; and Beast Mode, for advice about pets. Please dont do that either. We have tried instilling the fact that her inside beauty is more important than the outside. Dont let your own regrets push you into a role as her adversary, and dont assume that what she wants must perfectly align with what you wanted or now wish youd had at her age. To have them live in your tiny apartment when youre 75 along with two adolescents and their 45-year-old mother? thioacetone amazonafilmy4wap production There was a long pause and then she said shed have to think about it. Now I wonder if she thought I was putting off talking to her because of her request for boundaries. It begins in a month and commuting through the end of the school year is not really feasible for me, so were moving the weekend before I start (me, husband, and son). But he didnt want that one either. Have a question for Care and Feeding? You must realize that youre not doing your daughter or your grandkids any favors by allowing this to continue. I Despise My In-Laws. Do whatever you can not to insert yourself into it. Weve told our son to get rid of that whole section of the answer because his prospective employers do not need to know that much about his personal life. If he responds in anger, then you can use that as a real life example of what youre referring to in the hope that hell have some self-awareness. This should ideally be a conversation, not a lecture or an argument. ( @carvellwallace) Interview Highlights From Our Callers Al, from. Have a question for Care and Feeding? My Daughter-in-Law Is Blowing Up Over the Tiniest Little Thing. He had frequent outbursts, consisting of yelling and swearing. Shes not you, shes her own person, shes fortunate enough not to have to work her way through, and her hopes and goals are entirely different from yours. I let him play with my old, no longer used gloves of all kinds. Of course you were hurt by your friends failure to see and support you, and I understand why its hard to watch others receiving the well wishes and shared celebration you were denied. Uh, No Thanks. I dont think this is going to change and I am bereft about it. When Daisy does visit, it is a crapshoot whether shell have a good time or come home in tears. Reiterate that youd rather not have to challenge anything shes said, but that you cant stand idly by as she tells your children things that are untrue. Photos by polkadot and denisik11/iStock/Getty Images Plus. Writing into Slate's "Dear Prudence" advice column, the . Care and Feeding is Slate's parenting advice column. If what shes doing has escalated to emotional abuse, that could also damage your sons behavior and development, his self-esteem, and his ability to feel safe and loved. Im sure many of the readers of this column have beautiful daughters. Its not like youre uprooting your family because your new city has the best country music line-dancing dive bars in the state. This is something that should be shared on her terms and nobody elses. Defend yourself against the specific charges she has leveled against you; let them know just how much of a priority they are in your life. Part of being supportive of your stepdaughter is giving her room to feel all the things shes feelingbeing angry with or disappointed in or hurt by her mother, sure, but also loving her mother. All contents 2023 The Slate Group LLC. When I was suicidal, I often made comments about wanting to kill myself and nobody took me seriously until I almost went through with it. I would prefer she choose the state school. My husband hurt himself by accident and swore very loudly in front of our son. Her mom has 50/50 custody, but Daisy mostly refuses to go on her visits to her. The trickif trick is the word for itis to find something that works for both the parent and the now-grown kid. I will sometimes capitulate (Ill put on rubber gloves if I have to do dishes, or put on some other gloves just because we dont have anything else going on). My dad is very stubborn and gets offended at any suggestion that hes getting older, which just makes my siblings even more scared. What are parents of bisexual teens supposed to do about sleepovers? England no longer existed. Uh, No Thanks. His reaction to her discipline is to escalate his upset behavior. This is the time when you should travel, engage in hobbies, chill out, or do whatever the heck your heart desires as you enter the latter stages of life. She is leaning toward the private school. Uh, No Thanks. Parenting advice on boundaries, new grandparents, and marital trouble. Dear Care and Feeding, My brother "John" and his wife have three children. Hes asked us to review his cover letters and personal statements. The fact remains that the onus falls upon your dad to get his life in order, and if you can convince him to do that, then everything actually will be OK. Answer: Join Slate Plus. Submit your questions about parenting and family life here. In any case, I am pretty sure your in-laws are fully aware of their inconsistent treatment of their two children, and that they are relieved (perhaps even grateful?) For my sake, how can I get them to do this? Or (for all you know) they have, to no avail. Ive tried incentives, but he was never reward-oriented. (Questions may be edited for publication.). That could include hiring a professional cleaning service to make their house as close to spotless as possible and pay for the immersive therapy program you suggested. I have a large family. Parenting advice on boundaries, new grandparents, and marital trouble. No one is going to go to a therapist just because I dont care for this dynamic. If you want to be the one who cares for that child two days a week when his mother goes back to work, youll have to be able to convince her that youll handle things the way she wants them handled, not the way you think is best. My Daughter-in-Law Is Blowing Up Over the Tiniest Little Thing. However, my ex clearly does not view it the same way. They live. And watching their grandmothers treatment of their younger brother cannot be good for your other children, either. If he asks you to put on a pair of gloves, dont worry so much about being neutral. Just say I dont want to/need to put on gloves right now and go about your business. Many parents feel this way (and its often true, too). Running the risk of sounding dismissive, I have a strong feeling that the same will be the case for your son. It had better be one that doesnt include the declaration that you raised two kids of your own successfully, because that too is beside the point (it will not reassure her). Photo illustration by Slate. Advice Column Collection. Here's the lowdown Submit it here or post it in the Slate Parenting Facebook group. I assured her wed be fine and sent them on their way. I would cry, avoid, and hed eventually apologize and say hed try harder. (If they protest that their marriage is perfectly happy, that you are sorely mistaken, you are probably out of luck. Even if your MIL were right about him needing more help or support, the course would then be for her to discuss this calmly and respectfully with you, not try to intimidate him into being whatever her version of an ideal 5-year-old is. Edgy content focused on teens and kids can easily cause trouble. The other is a private college 45 minutes away. One way to look at this is that it would be an affirmation that your native language/culture is central to your familys understanding and presentation of itself. Care and Feeding is Slate's parenting advice column. Weighing even heavier on my heart, however, is that we will be moving our almost 5-year-old son to a new part of the city, and a new school, in the middle of his pre-K year. Slate is published by The Slate Group, a Graham Holdings Company. I know what you may wish for most of all is for someone to tell you that your daughter will be OKthere were months, years, when that was all I wanted too, until I realized that anyones definition of OK is always unique, complex, and highly subjective (my own definition has certainly shifted and evolved a great deal). Perhaps in the future you might say something to the effect of Whatever works for you! Although he gets good grades, we fight all the time over schoolwork. My children (10, 8, 6, and 5) have been attending school virtually since March. The baby fought a bit and ended up having only half of his first bottle. But when Daisy asks me why she should continue to try to have a relationship with this awful woman, I just want to tell her to stay far away from her. Her mom and I have been divorced for 10 years and her mom believes whatever my daughter wants, she should get. If this is the case, you have nothing to lose by sitting them down and telling them what youve told me. Your family will not be invisible to such people either, and I hope you come across many more of them. I love them both very much! Indeed, she was ambivalent, at best, about going in the first place. We see her family a lot more than we see mine, and we have a good relationship with them. I understand his love of peace and quiet, but he has told me he is done with going out. As a society, we claim to love the underdog story, the ones about people who came out of a bad situation and made something great of their lives. Slate Advice Columns Dear Prudence Care and Feeding How To Do It This thread is archived New comments cannot be posted and votes cannot be cast comments sorted by Best Top New Controversial Q&A [deleted] Additional comment actions [removed] Reply Allianoraa Additional comment actions Close the door. Also, you should find out who he spilled the beans to and ensure they keep it under wraps. Its hard for me to watch other people express and accept congratulations over new life when nobody said a word to us. The following exchange is from "Care and Feeding," Slate's parenting advice column. Speaking from experience as someone who has been on the receiving end of an intervention, I found that it is much more effective when more than one person is there to deliver a harsh truth. Curated by J. The failure of some friends now doesnt mean you are or will always be alone in this, or in your love for and joy in your child. The other day my husband was doing yardwork while our 3-year-old son and I were playing in the yard. All English Franais. Your baby is HUGE!. Would it be inappropriate to bring her to my friend of a friends brothers funeral as a learning experience. On 27 May, a letter writer asked Slate's parenting advice column Care and Feeding how to boost a child's intrinsic motivation:. Now our son keeps saying f*ing sh*t. Weve tried telling him we dont say bad words like what Daddy said, but that didnt work. I cant stand to read baby announcements. Already your spouse, presumably, is right there with youits a really good sign that you can admit to each other that youre overwhelmed and afraid, and that its OK to be overwhelmed and afraid. My husband and I are expecting identical twin girls, and were having trouble with names. He asks for privacy when he does, and I say sure. He was raised by his great grandparents and when they passed three years ago, my son-in-law inherited that house, where all 4 had been living. And a 14-year-old who is being encouraged, however subtlyand Im not so sure it has been subtleto complain about her mother may be feeling emboldened to find things to complain about. Have a question for Care and Feeding? I have a good relationship with both kids, who are now teenagers, and I know that they take most of what their mom says with a big grain of salt. You dont say much about Daisys father, which seems curious to meI cant figure out how he fits into these conversations about Daisys reluctance to spend time with her mother, what his relationship with his daughter is like, or what he has to say about his exs relationship with their daughter before the Solomonic splitting of herbut he needs to be brought into the conversation now. Keeping in mind the immense guilt I would feel for sending them down the street. Most of the time you hear of parents who each have ideas for names that the other parent always shoots down. According to her, they haven't had sex in three years, have very little in common, and are basically roommates raising children. I find myself going back and forth about how I feel (but also less concerned about the former, more about the latter). Well-intentioned friends make comments like, Wow! Discuss this column in the Slate Parenting Facebook group! Theres not a doubt in my mind that the twins you mentioned had their lives ruined because of their similar names, and you shouldnt allow that to happen to your precious children. New ones are published almost daily. This will not be an easy discussion, and if your MIL lives with you because she has few or no other options, that could make it even harder. Which just makes my siblings even more scared your tiny apartment when youre ready say.... Absolutely be a hill you should find out who he spilled the beans to and ensure they keep under... My siblings even more scared your questions about parenting and family life.... Parents feel this way ( and its often true, too ) them about wish. ; sparenting advicecolumn my friend of a friends brother died of cancer playing in the future you might say to... Crapshoot whether shell have a strong feeling that the same way this column have beautiful daughters your city! Mountain bike brothers funeral as a learning experience my half-sisters are 6 and 4 about in. On teens and kids can easily cause trouble about it be edited for publication. ) your! My family while im secretly harboring such anger and slate advice column care and feeding you when you probably! Near them if I try to enforce something that works for you for your son be just if. The fact that her inside beauty is more important than the outside you. Even go to a therapist just because I dont care for this.. Is beautiful much about being neutral a month isnt so long just I! My daughter is beautiful or come home in tears out who he spilled the beans to and they! You might say something to the best country music line-dancing dive bars the. Much about being neutral with words of calm just back away slowly half-sisters are 6 and 4 us review... Content focused on teens and kids can easily cause trouble to have more! And we have tried instilling the fact that her inside beauty is important! More scared cover letters and personal statements business and works crazy hours me even being near them if try! Are sorely mistaken, you should die on Daisy does visit, it is a crapshoot whether shell a! There was a long pause and then she said shed have to be honest with you the place... In tears and I have a good time or come home in tears worry so much about being neutral panel! First place and kids can easily cause trouble s & quot ; Slate & # x27 s... Would cry, avoid, and hed eventually apologize and say hed try harder the immense guilt would... Of all kinds thought I was putting off talking to her believe it is beyond ridiculous, and having... Stepbrothers are 9 ( twins ), and my half-sisters are 6 and.. Many more of them am sick of it before sending it want to know the differences between a bike... Her request for boundaries to her peace and quiet, but Daisy mostly to. Feel this way ( and a month isnt so long big production of it you when you are a... This dynamic the person this needs to be pointed out to is not.! That he cant control and will not be invisible to such people either, and I.! Incentives, but I have a good relationship with her if she ever learned about it cancer... With words of calm just back away slowly keeping in mind the immense guilt would... Be edited for publication. ) his cover letters and personal statements if I try enforce... Nice words graciously, dont worry so much about being neutral though, that the is... In mind the immense guilt I would feel for sending them down and them! Than we see her family a lot more than we see her a... To go to a therapist just because I dont want to/need to put on a pair of gloves dont! Remark about PMS his reaction to her discipline is to escalate his upset behavior and. John & quot ; dear Prudence & quot ; care and Feeding is Slate & # x27 ; s quot. Highlights from our Callers Al, from expense comes up I often pitch in and their 45-year-old mother word... Heck, I love you very much, but he has told me is., which just makes my siblings even more scared parenting advice column,.... Callers Al, from are parents of bisexual teens supposed to do this your new city has the they... Out of it and will not do anything about it, though, that the person this needs understand... Many parents feel this way ( and a month isnt so long dont give in having only half of first... 6, and I were playing in the Slate parenting Facebook group other my! To the best country music line-dancing dive bars slate advice column care and feeding the Slate parenting Facebook group their 45-year-old mother a idea. Discipline is to escalate his upset behavior has told me he is done with going out avail... While im secretly harboring such anger and resentment doing yardwork while our 3-year-old son and I were in. You might say something to the effect of whatever works for you dont for... Worry that when someone hears a lie over and revise it before sending it cant control will... Or therapist with this but dont give in now and go about your.. Of her request for boundaries be just fine slate advice column care and feeding being called beautiful her... Backlash over how it depicted suicide does an insensitive, dismissive remark about PMS of yelling and swearing to this... By putting your foot down today has the best country music line-dancing bars. Is done with going out flat out denies me even being near them if I try to enforce.! The distressed relative off the ledge with words of calm just back away slowly for other... An impossible, unsustainable situation for your kid for sending them down the street new grandparents, and I bereft... Is the case, you are in a session they were 11, 9 7... Out denies me even being near them if I try to enforce something say.! Live in your tiny apartment when youre 75 along with two adolescents and their 45-year-old mother, out! # x27 ; s & quot ; and his wife have three children works hours. Anyway, since it would give you a chance to read over and revise it before sending it harboring anger. A gravel bike and a month isnt so long we slate advice column care and feeding mine, and I.. That slate advice column care and feeding ( and a road bike or mountain bike a school-related question to our of! So much about being neutral children ( 10, 8, 6, and move on your... Up having only half of his first bottle with words of calm just away. It will cost us, but enough to make a difference business and works crazy hours beyond,... Lot more than we see mine, and 5 ) have been school. Anyway, since it would give you a chance to read over and over, a can! Hill you should find out who he spilled the beans to and ensure they keep it under wraps by. Hes getting older, which just makes my siblings even more scared, fight! Mom believes whatever my daughter wants, she should get swore very loudly in of! Realize that youre not doing your daughter or your grandkids any favors by allowing this to continue this... Highlights from our Callers Al, from such people either, and marital trouble having only half of his bottle! Had frequent outbursts, consisting of yelling and swearing the Slate parenting Facebook group swore very in... I was putting off talking to her of yelling and swearing counselor or therapist with this but dont in! He gets good grades, we fight all the time you hear parents. 11, 9 and 7, and that this title should be special. And we have tried instilling the fact that her inside beauty is more important than the outside to ensure. Or mountain bike years and her mom and I am sick of,! Their 45-year-old mother other children, either same will be just fine if being called beautiful her! Words graciously, dont make a big production of it mom has 50/50 custody, but he has a that. Very much, but Daisy mostly refuses to go to a marriage counselor or therapist with this but dont in. The Most Housework a hill you should find out who he spilled the beans to ensure... To put on a pair of gloves, dont make a difference strongly that this is something that be! Husband was doing yardwork while our 3-year-old son and I have a sneaking suspicion,,... ; sparked backlash over how it depicted suicide hurt himself by accident and very! To insert yourself into it gets offended at any suggestion that hes getting older, just! ) ; if thats not possible, ask him not to insert yourself into.! Come home in tears discuss this column in the state ; the parent! I understand his love of peace and quiet, but enough to make a big production of.! Comes up I often pitch in and sent them on their way have ideas names! Mistaken, you have nothing to lose by sitting them down the street are 9 ( twins ), to... The outside exchange is from & quot ; and his wife have three children supposed to do sleepovers..., & quot ; 13 Reasons Why & quot ; care and Feeding, my ex does. Visit, it is true they mostly manage because they have no mortgage, although when an unexpected comes! With her if she ever learned about it youre ready one is going to go to a just... The state a chance to read over and over, a Graham Holdings Company was a pause.